|
Time to tell them how the Chinese feel
Li Xing
I
have been receiving more emails from overseas these days than usual.
Writing from India, Australia, the United States and elsewhere, some
readers hope to make me, and more Chinese through me, understand their
points of view. One Tibetan, living in India, wrote to me, saying that
the "Tibetans in exile are seeking autonomy and not freedom and that our
means of realizing this goal is through peace and non-violence. There
are times when our adrenaline does the talking, we break things, we
shout, we cry but physically harming and hitting people is out of the
question".
On Monday, he and another reader sent me the article by Grace Wang from
Duke University published in Washington Post, talking about how she "was
treated so shabbily by her fellow-Chinese when she tried to mediate a
dispute between Chinese and Tibetan students".
While accepting their good intentions, I can sense their frustration and
even anger at the fact that the Chinese worldwide have rallied together
in support of the Beijing Olympics and condemned the recent riots in
Lhasa and some Tibetan-populated areas in neighboring provinces.
They reason with me, saying that we Chinese at home get only "censored"
information and do not get the whole picture. And for those overseas
Chinese worldwide, who have every access to every major and minor
Western media outlet and who have also spoken up, the only explanation
is they are "brainwashed". Above all, they say, there is a great
misunderstanding between the Chinese and the Westerners they represent.
To bridge the gap between differing points of view, the Chinese must do
better to understand the West and make China better understood by the
West. James A. Millward even wrote a special Public Relations 101 for
China on www.opendemocracy.net. While agreeing with some of Millward's
points, I believe many in the West, including the Tibetans from India,
have missed a point that a netizen made about Mr Millward's lecture.
"How can the West better understand China", the netizen asked, "what are
the ways to avoid unfounded statements and opinions about China getting
splashed across the Western media?"
In fact, it is the prejudice against China and other developing
countries that has sowed the seeds of misunderstanding and
miscommunication. The force that has united most of the Chinese
worldwide is not the result of simple propaganda, but born of bitter
experiences for more than a century in our relations with the West, ever
since it forced open the doors of China with guns and opium. One work
that best summarizes the twists and turns that the Chinese have gone
through on the country's road to modernization is How the Chinese Feel,
a verse being circulated via emails among the Chinese worldwide.
I have been trying to identify its writer, but have yet to succeed. I
have to beg the writer's indulgence for quoting a part from his work :
We tried Communism to equalize, You hated us for being Communists. Now
we embrace free trade and privatize, You berated us for being
Mercantilist (And since you made up that word, you must know what it
means, as we don't). HALT! You demanded: a billion-three who eat well
will destroy the planet!
So we tried birth control, then You blasted us for human rights abuse.
As Gregory Clark, a former officer in Australia's Department of External
Affairs, wrote in a Japan Times' opinion article, "China, it seems, just
can't win, no matter what it does. It is the 6-ton elephant that
everyone likes to bash." I am proud that most Chinese have learned that
we need not curry favor with the West at the expense of our principles,
our national sovereignty and our territorial integrity. We must not lose
sight of our social and economic imperatives and of the challenges that
we must overcome today despite the Western clamor.
—The Daily Mail-China Daily news exchange item |