|
Fake photos tarnish the news media
My
husband and I once tried to remove a few electrical cables hanging over
a beautiful bridge in a photograph that my husband took in Ottawa a
decade ago. The miracle tool was none other than Photoshop.
A couple of hours later, we accomplished what we set out to do, but the
touched-up bridge did not look any better than the original photograph.
After all, we were not, and still not, conversant with the wonder
computer software. And I believe in my line of work, it is better to
remain a little ignorant of the multiple imaging tools that Photoshop
offers so as not to be enticed into committing such a mortal sin as
distorting news photographs.
But sadly, some professional as well as amateur news photographers
around the world have not been able to resist the temptation. The latest
scandal involves a photographer working with the Daqing Evening News
newspaper in the oil capital of Daqing, Heilongjiang province. He
doctored two photographs he had taken and turned them into a composite
of Tibetan antelopes crossing near a bridge on the Qinghai-Tibet Railway
as a train passes.
He submitted his work in a news photograph competition held by CCTV, the
national TV network, and won a prize.
Despite the initial failure at detection, the Daqing Evening News made
the right decision on Monday to fire the photographer. The
editor-in-chief of the newspaper also resigned.
While we support the paper's decision, we must also recognize the fact
that the scandal has sent out a clear warning. It is not the first time
the media has come across doctored or staged photographs.
Two years ago, the World Press Photo awarded a third prize to a
photograph entitled Wedding During SARS. It featured a newly-wed couple
crossing a street in Wuhan in their wedding outfits, and each wearing a
mask.
Soon after the news of the award reached China, the "groom" in the
photograph brought the photographer to court. He revealed that the
"wedding" was staged and that he and the young woman in the photograph
were actually models. The popularity of the photograph had done him much
harm as he was in fact planning to get married.
Also a few years ago, I received from a freelancer several photographs
showing how a major Siberian tiger-breeding center was thriving with
dozens of the felines roaming on a snow-covered field. At once, my
photographer colleagues warned me that they could be fakes. "No two
tigers should look alike, but here some do," one of them said.
I believe many other media people must have had similar experiences.
Last September, five of the country's websites for news photographs
jointly declared they would refuse to accept photographs that had been
digitally doctored. The websites required all contracted photographers
follow professional ethics and maintain high standards.
It is believed that some photographers, familiar with the Tibet
autonomous region and Tibetan antelopes, had doubts about the
authenticity of the photograph during the screening process of the CCTV
competition. However, apparently no one raised their doubts openly and
let the photograph slip through.
What does that teach us? We should always be vigilant against fakes, and
double-check for doctored news photographs.
—The Daily Mail, China Daily news exchange item |