US report on Iraq ‘insulting’, says Talabani
Middle East Desk Report

BAGHDAD—President Jalal Talabani, a long-time US ally, has made a stinging attack on the controversial Iraq Study Group report, calling it “dangerous” and insulting to Iraqi sovereignty. The report’s recommendations were also implicitly criticised by outgoing defence secretary Donald Rumsfeld, who paid a defiant farewell visit to US troops and urged them to stay the course.
Four days after the release of the report, which was hailed by many US lawmakers and commentators as pointing to a way out of the Iraq crisis, Talabani invited journalists to his Baghdad villa to denounce it. “If you read this report one would think that it is written for a young, small colony that they are imposing conditions on, neglecting the fact that we are a sovereign country, and respected,” he said.
The president was angered by the recommendation that more US troops be directly assigned to Iraqi army units, demanding instead that Prime Minister Nuri al-Maliki be given full command of all Iraqi forces. “As a whole, I reject this report,” he said. “I think that the Baker-Hamilton report is not fair and not just, and it contains dangerous articles which undermine the sovereignty of Iraq and its consitution.”
The report — seen in Washington as an indictment of President George W. Bush’s strategy in Iraq — was written by 10 former officials working under former secretary of state James Baker. Talabani’s most scathing attack on the report was on Baker himself, who in Iraq is seen as reponsible for the fateful US decision not to overthrow Saddam Hussein in 1991 after expelling his forces from Kuwait.
“We smell in this report the attitude of James Baker in the aftermath of the war in Kuwait,” Talabani said. Talabani said he would write to US President George W. Bush — whom he described as “courageous — to outline Iraq’s objections to the study group’s advice, much of which the US leader has already discarded.
Bush’s former point man on Iraq, Rumsfeld, was unapologetic during his farewell visit to Iraq about his views and strategies in the conflict, which were broadly criticised in the report. In front of thousands of cheering soldiers at two different US military bases, Rumsfeld defiantly repeated his justifications for the war and the need to stick to it, according to an American Forces Press Service article.
“We feel great urgency to protect the American people from another 9/11 or a 9/11 times two or three,” Rumsfeld said Saturday at al-Asad base in a remote part of Al-Anbar province. “At the same time, we need to have the patience to see this task through to success,” Rumsfeld said, according to the article on the Pentagon website. “The enemy must be defeated,” he added, predicting that the US “war on terror” would be a Cold War-like struggle that would take half a century. Rumsfeld left for Iraq on Friday from Washington, but it was not until late Saturday that the Pentagon revealed he had made the trip, a final chance to express appreciation to the troops.
US officials in Baghdad on Sunday would still not comment on his trip. The visit coincided with the death of two marines, bringing the toll of US military dead since the March 2003 invasion to 2,927. More than 40 have died in the first week of December alone. Violence elsewhere in the country continued unabated with at least 26 people killed, including nine in a vicious sectarian attack when two Shiite families were attacked in the west Baghdad neighbourhood of Jihad. In the nearby Amil neighbourhood, five people were killed in clashes between Sunni tribesmen and Shiite militias.
A total of 17 bodies were also found in Baghdad, including three without heads in the Sunni neighbourhood of Hurriya, an increasingly frequent site of sectarian clashes. The Iraq report strongly warns against the mounting sectarian strife in the country, including in its recommendations that the prime minister should work harder to reconcile the nation’s fractured political factions.