|
People’s victory
LEBANON, and with it the rest of the world, heaved an almost audible
sigh of relief with this disastrous war coming to an end on Monday. The
guns have fallen silent, after incessantly spitting fire for more than a
month. It looks like the tenuous truce is holding, for now. The ever
optimistic and enterprising people of Lebanon have started returning to
their homes, or whatever is left of them. But even for them, used to the
long civil war and earlier Israeli occupation, rebuilding their country
all over again from a scratch is not going to be easy. The once booming
Lebanon has been reduced to rubble and ruins. Rebuilding it is going to
be a truly Herculean task.
More than the task of rebuilding their country and their lives, it is
the fear of their uncertain future that is hard to handle for the
people. While peace prevails now, there is no guarantee that it is going
to continue tomorrow or in the days to come. Especially since Israel has
failed to achieve any of its original or stated objectives — the return
of its captured soldiers and the elimination of Hezbollah threat — there
are fears that a frustrated Israeli leadership could resort to familiar
war games.
Prime Minister Ehud Olmert is already under fire at home for
‘mismanaging’ the Lebanon crisis and swallowing more than he could chew.
So the Israelis yesterday listened to Olmert’s jingoistic rhetoric in
the Knesset with a heavy dose of scepticism. Even as the prime minister
was vowing on Monday never to ‘forget and forgive’ Israel’s ‘enemies’
(read Hezbollah), Shaikh Hassan Nasrallah was declaring a ‘historic
victory’ in the war.
It is not possible to question Hezbollah’s claim. After all, this
rag-tag army of irregulars, with their antiquated arms, managed to hold
against one of the most powerful armies in the world for more than a
month. Although there are no winners in this war, if any side can claim
victory, it is certainly not Israel. It’s the people of Lebanon who have
prevailed. They have managed to accomplish what many powerful Arab
governments and armies failed to achieve.
But now Lebanon needs all the support and help from the international
community it can get. Sweden is hosting an international aid conference
later this month with representatives of more than 60 governments and
organisations taking part to discuss the urgent relief and rebuilding
effort in Lebanon. It is time for the world community to show it cares
for the unfortunate people of Lebanon.
Confronting the past
As we hope the echoes of the Lebanese conflict fade away, on the other
side of the world memories of another bloody war have been stirred.
Japanese Premier Junichiro Koizumi has again paid his respects at a
Tokyo war shrine which honors Japan’s war dead; the shrine includes the
names of 14 individuals executed for war crimes after the country’s
defeat. Koizumi’s continued insistence on attending this ceremony has
produced renewed protests from the Chinese and South Koreans whose
people suffered terribly from Japanese aggression.
Yet the Yasukuni Shrine, originally built in 1869 to commemorate the
dead in a civil war, is also a memorial to the 2.4 million Japanese who
died in World War II. The majority were ordinary soldiers and civilians
who, all things being equal, should quite rightly have been shown a mark
of respect by later generations.
But all things are not equal. Japan may have apologized for the
barbarous behavior of its armies but there is enduring evidence that
they have not themselves accepted that their nation was in fact guilty
of terrible crimes. The controversial school textbooks, which sought to
gloss over the facts of the horrific protracted 1937 massacre of
possibly 300,000 Chinese in the captured city of Nanjing, are only part
of the evidence of this refusal to admit the reality of what their
ancestors did. Instead, largely because of the destruction of Hiroshima
and Nagasaki by atom bombs which claimed over 214,000 lives and the
equal death toll in the Tokyo firestorms caused by American bombing, the
Japanese have chosen to see themselves as victims rather than
aggressors.
The Germans, on the other hand, have not only admitted but accepted in
their hearts the murderous depravity of the Nazis. If Chancellor Angela
Merkel were to make a high profile visit to a war memorial to German
dead, there would be no protest from Russians or Jews or any other
victims of the Hitler regime. The Japanese, however, have been unable to
look their past squarely in the face. Because of this, their former
victims can take the view that the arrogant racial supremacist beliefs
that informed Japan’s appalling treatment of those they conquered have
not really changed.
Nevertheless, it is hard not to suspect that the Chinese and Koreans are
trying to make political capital out of Koizumi’s behavior. It is
notable that there have been no similar protests from other Southeast
Asian countries which were also subject to Japanese occupation. Nor have
Allied governments whose troops died by the thousands in POW camps
raised objections. Perhaps this is because there is a wider recognition
that, in the end, it is the Japanese who will suffer from this continued
denial of their past. The balance of world power is swinging inexorably
to Asia, following the path of economic growth that the Japanese
themselves pioneered in their remarkable postwar recovery. But as long
as Japan denies its own history, it will also deny itself the key role
that it should play as the region’s most mature and sophisticated
economy.
—Arab News |