|
Transparency in relief
operations
WHILE the international response to the enormous need for relief to the
survivors of the monumental tragedy continues to be reasonably
encouraging, the commitments made by donors for the gigantic task ahead
fall much short of the estimates for the rebuilding of infrastructure
and homes of around four million people devastated by the killer
earthquake. In the beginning, it was estimated that close to US$5
billion would be required for the reconstruction stage but as relief
workers move into hitherto blocked and inaccessible areas, the scale of
widespread damage has already been termed unimaginable. Suddenly death
toll has jumped to some 79,000 but those who have managed to see for
themselves the extent of devastation in various areas are of the view
that the October 8 calamity may have claimed not less than 250,000
lives. In addition, it is believed that as many as 4,000 hamlets,
villages, towns and cities like Muzaffarabad, Bagh and Balakot have been
almost wiped out. According to official statements, 15% debris are yet
to be removed in Azad Kashmir’s once sprawling capital of 500,000 souls
and underneath lie buried thousands of persons whose bodies are yet to
be recovered. Same applies to other areas. Bodies of tens of thousands
could not be pulled out even after over a month of the colossal disaster
from the debris of collapsed houses and other structures in a vast area.
The Donors ‘conference is taking place in Islamabad on 19th November at
which the President will personally brief the world on what had happened
and what Pakistan needs for the all too important phase of rebuilding
the shattered homes, educational institutions, hospitals, bridges, roads
and other infrastructure. We surely require at least US$10 billion
against which around 10% has so far been committed. Compared to
international community’s adequate response to Tsunami tragedy, Pakistan
earthquake case has not been properly projected. Certainly there is no
discrimination on the basis of religion. One may pause and ask as to why
the foreign donors are not responding appropriately to post-earthquake
requirements. It is possible that we as a country have been placed at
Number 14 of the list of most corrupt states in the recent report of the
Transparency International. The donors perhaps feel that in view of
massive corruption in Pakistan’s civilian departments, their money would
not largely got o the deserving victims. President Pervez Musharraf has
time and again assured every one involved in the relief operations that
all expenditures shall be incurred in the most transparent manner. The
distribution of relief goods is being done by the troops. Already, at a
few places our soldiers have acted swiftly to nab those who were
involved in malpractices including hoarding of relief goods. Army
engineers will supervise the reconstruction phase. The reconstruction
task shall be coordinated by the Engineer-in-Chief of the Pakistan Army.
Obviously, relief and reconstructions activities will not be handled
directly by civilian departments.
With the direct involvement of the Army in the relief and reconstruction
work, funds being donated by the people and the other donors including
international agencies, NGOs, Foreign Governments, etc, will hopefully
be utilized properly. The chances of misappropriations will be greatly
minimized. However, Army authorities must understand that the corrupt
mafia will try to siphon off some of the funds. They will, as ever,
hopefully show no clemency to such unscrupulous elements. Unfortunately,
corruption at lower level could not be eliminated due to political
interference but the authority headed by a three star General to oversee
the reconstruction phase will not be influenced by party or other
considerations. The donors should be grudge giving a lot more money to
mitigate the sufferings of the millions affected by the earthquake.
The road ahead for
Azerbaijan
AZERBAIJAN
is a classic example of poverty co-existing with oil wealth. Though it
is relatively a latecomer on to the booming global energy market, the
current high oil prices are boosting Baku’s revenues. Its GDP last year
was $30 billion and it is expected to double by 2008. If the country’s
massive oil and gas reserves, one of the richest in the world, are
exploited properly, Azerbaijan’s revenues will go up further in the
coming years. But the question being asked is how much of the oil income
goes towards uplifting the poor in remote and rural areas of the
country. According to official statistics, 40 per cent of Azeris live
below the poverty line of $41.20 a month and inflation is running in
double digits. Like many developing countries, Azerbaijan, despite its
enormous hydrocarbon wealth, is bedevilled by poor infrastructure,
clannish loyalties and above all corruption, which is fuelled by
millions of dollars flowing into the country from oil and gas deals.
Although the petrodollar income is rising, it is not helping the
country’s poor much; rather, it’s only exacerbating the wealth gap,
because a lot of money is going into the pockets of high and mighty
fiefs and other vested interest groups, stymieing the country’s growth.
Besides oil wealth, Azerbaijan has vast Caspian Sea riches that are yet
to be tapped and its beautiful beaches can be turned into tourist
paradises. To develop these resources, Baku needs massive doses of
foreign aid and technology. Unless there is a firm political commitment
and will, it’s not possible for the Azeri leadership to put the country
on the path to economic prosperity. The very fact that Azerbaijan ranks
101 in the 177-nation UN Human Development Index shows how far it is
trailing behind others. Tomorrow’s parliamentary polls are a crucial
test for the present government of President Ilham Aliev, who is
expected to romp home without any difficulty as the opposition parties
are in disarray. But the opposition groups see plans to rig the vote
while the government fears disturbances, engineered by the rivals,
during the elections, which have generated considerable interest in the
West, particularly in the US, because of Azerbaijan’s strategic
importance as an oil source alternative to the Middle East. Whatever the
poll outcome, the future government’s agenda is clear: The new team has
to strive for equitable distribution of wealth through a slew of radical
economic and social reforms. Otherwise, tensions are bound to rise and
the poor-rich gap will continue to widen further.
—Khaleej Times |